How does a self-directed IRA work?
[site-breadcrumb]
A self-directed individual retirement account (IRA) is a variety of traditional or Roth IRAs that allows you to invest in assets that are not available to holders of conventional IRAs. In other words, this is a tax-advantaged retirement account that you control. Despite the fact that the account is administered by a custodian or trustee, you get to manage the account directly – hence the name “self-directed.” Even though self-directed IRAs can be an attractive investment option, they are not recommended for the average investor. Read our article to find out why.
Self-directed IRA
How does a self-directed IRA work?
Self-Directed IRAs Explained: Greater Control Over Retirement Investments
In many respects, a self-directed IRA functions similarly to a traditional Individual Retirement Account. To open one, you must have earned income, and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) applies the same annual contribution limits. For example, individuals can contribute up to $6,000 per year, or $7,000 if they are aged 50 or older. A self-directed IRA can also be structured as either a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA, following the same tax deduction and income eligibility rules.
The primary distinction between a standard IRA and a self-directed IRA lies in the range of investments allowed. With a self-directed account, investors gain access to a broader selection of assets, including alternative investments such as commodities, real estate, limited partnerships, tax lien certificates, private placements, and even cryptocurrencies. In contrast, traditional IRA accounts are typically limited to conventional investments like stocks, bonds, certificates of deposit, mutual funds, and exchange-traded funds (ETFs).
Despite this broader flexibility, certain prohibited investments still apply. Self-directed IRAs cannot hold life insurance policies, S corporation stock, or collectibles, including items such as antiques, artwork, jewelry, stamps, and rare coins.
Although funds in a self-directed IRA generally cannot be withdrawn without penalties until retirement age, the account holder can actively manage the portfolio and choose how the money is invested at any time.
It is also important to note that not all IRA providers offer self-directed accounts. If you want to open one, you will need to work with a specialized IRA custodian that supports these types of investments. Custodians may differ in the investment options they support, so reviewing their services carefully before opening an account is advisable. Additionally, alternative assets cannot usually be purchased directly from the custodian—you typically need to acquire them through an external provider.
Finally, regulations prohibit self-directed IRA custodians from providing financial or investment advice. As a result, investors are responsible for evaluating the risks of their chosen investments, although they can still seek guidance from independent financial advisors if needed.
Self-directed IRA
Risks of a self-directed IRA
While building a more diversified portfolio can lead to more lucrative returns, investing in alternative assets also involves much higher risks. Unless you are a financially savvy investor who understands the nature of such investments, there is a risk that your investments will underperform benchmark indexes.
Expect limited liquidity with some of your investments as selling alternative assets like real estate can take much longer than selling a stock. If you need to liquidate an investment, you may end up selling for much less than market value or the purchase price.
Fees are one of the key drawbacks of having a self-directed IRA. Your custodian will most likely charge you for establishing the account, on top of annual fees and service fees for any tasks they handle.
You may also want to familiarize yourself with the IRS rules on self-directed IRAs, the most important of which relate to disqualified individuals and prohibited transactions. The IRS prohibits purchasing assets or selling assets to disqualified persons. In addition to yourself as the owner of the account, each ascendant and descendant in your family and their spouses are also disqualified persons. The list includes any corporation, estate, partnership, or trust where a disqualified person owns 50% or more of the interests as well as a director, an officer, or a 10%-or-greater shareholder of any of these entities.
IRS rules also prohibit you from immediately or directly benefiting from the assets in your account. There are several prohibited transactions, like self-dealing or investing in a business owned by a family member.